9) Eminem as Aragorn
8) Britney Spears as an orc (heh...)
7) Russell Crowe for Pippin
6) Johnny Depp for Gandalf
5) Robin Williams for Elrond
4) Keanu Reeves for Merry
3) Arnold Schwarzeneger for Legolas
2) Britney Spears for Arwen (HA!)
And the number 1 worst original casting choice for LOTR is...
Sylvester Stallone for Frodo!!!!
bravenet.com